Zaza and Baggio’s are the two I normally think of. Both basically sending Italy out of two major tournaments.
Simone Zaza euro 2016 Germany vs Italy
Not quite answering your question, but probably the most iconic redemption penalty would be Pearce at Euro 96 after his miss in Italia 90
JT in the UCL final against Man United?
In England, it has to be Southgate vs Germany in Euro 96
Still talked about to this day
One that’s very popular cause it ends in a rival’s goal is Leicester vs Watford in the 2013 Championship Play-Off. Idk what Leicester player misses but then is a counter attack and Deeney gives Watford the victory.
Zico against France in '86 during regulation time.
Baggio
Beckham’s outer space pen in shootout euro q/final in 2004 vs Portugal.Of course he looked to blame it on the condition of the pen spot.
Baggio 94 Asamoah Gyan 2010 Maybe Juanfran in 2016, but less because of him and more because of the Madrid Derby and because it kickstarted Real’s treble of CL’s
Personally I think Baggio is the most iconic one. To this day we still remember the phrase “Socrates died poisoned, and Baggio died standing”
Jaap Stam 2004
Club football wise, John Terry for sure.
- Baggio
- Trezeguet vs Italy
- Knockaert vs Watford
- Ghana vs Uruguay
Baggio 94 and Southgate 96 for me I guess they are my earliest memories of major penalty shootout failures.
It’s either Baggio or Terry.
Take your pick.
John Terry ECL.