Really bad take. All stories borrow elements from other stories but this took it to a rediculous level.
Saying that Star Wars stole from Dune because both Paul and Luke are names that appear in the Bible or because they both used electric binoculars is nuts. And that’s just a couple examples.
Lucas himself said he took elements of Dune and incorporated it. Everyone is forgetting Kurosawa too.
Star Wars stole everything from Flash Gordon too
And Jack Kirby. Even, somehow, Hamill’s motorcycle scars.
Dune, star wars, superman all stole from John carter. So did Flash Gordon, Buck Rogers and loads of others. Dune seems to always get the credit though.
John Carter stole The Odyssey, which stole from Gilgamesh, who stole from Enheduanna, who stole from the neolithic artists of Sayburç, who stole from the paleolithic cave artists of Cáceres, who were alive around 75,000 years ago, or about 240,000 years after modern humans first evolved. They probably stole from someone in those 240,000 years.
It gets tiring, but if it’s an interesting story it does not matter.
Begun, the Nerd War has…
