Funny, I can point to at least 50 Democratic and capitalist countries that run just fine and are in the top 10 best countries to live in on the earth. But you can’t name just one viable country run by a communist government?
Because human progress is about making things that do not exist. Saying that something doesn’t exist currently does not mean it cannot exist.
Before the french revolution there were no democratic countries. back then you could say “Name one democratic country. Oh you can’t? Guess democracy doesn’t work.” and it would be just as valid as your claim now.
Fair point but communism hasn’t been effectively implemented because it’s being purposely stifled, it’s because it’s a crap system.
I guess if you take the best aspects of communism and ignore the history of how shitty it is then maybe you can theoretically imagine a successful version of it. But I don’t need to hypothesize such a scenario. There’s plenty of data and historical facts that completely prove my point
Humanity has progressed a lot in even the last 20 years. Using historical facts to prove something doesn’t work is not effective under these circumstances.
Also communism (in the classical sense) doesn’t really have a practical history, as no country on the planet has purposefully reached it.
The soviet union or china were never communist. They were both horrific state capitalist dictatorships.
And capitalism is also crap. For example look at the impending climate catastrophe.
I’ll never say capitalism is perfect but it’s a system that works - and at its best, it works remarkably well. I hear this argument a lot that communism hasn’t implemented the way it should be. Has there ever been a government that came close to what you would consider “almost good enough” communism?
Communism is by definition a stateless, moneyless, classless society. If any of these exist it is not communism.
There is no “almost good enough”. You can’t have almost classless.
If you have classes you aren’t classless, and in a single party system the party members are a class.
I put it to you that capitalism doesn’t work. It is an inherently corrupt system that will inevitably end in the destruction of everything.
Capitalism is unsustainable. Built on the myth of perpetual growth and willing to kill everything on this planet to achieve that.
Given a long enough time-frame all wealth and decision making capabilities under a capitalism will be consolidated in the hands of a couple of rich companies that will only care about economic growth. Damn the consequences.
/sidenote. I am not actually a communist but an Anarchist. I oppose all unjust hierarchies.
Money, state and class just happen to all fit under this definition and because of that I also support communism.
You could say the same for democratic governments before French revolution.
Funny, I can point to at least 50 Democratic and capitalist countries that run just fine and are in the top 10 best countries to live in on the earth. But you can’t name just one viable country run by a communist government?
Funny how that works 😂🤔
I said before the French revolution.
Also I doubt they are going to be “the best” after climate change (which is caused by those countries) causes them to collapse.
Why is it so hard to name one successful, current communist country?
Forget about your French revolution nonsense 😂
Because human progress is about making things that do not exist. Saying that something doesn’t exist currently does not mean it cannot exist.
Before the french revolution there were no democratic countries. back then you could say “Name one democratic country. Oh you can’t? Guess democracy doesn’t work.” and it would be just as valid as your claim now.
Fair point but communism hasn’t been effectively implemented because it’s being purposely stifled, it’s because it’s a crap system.
I guess if you take the best aspects of communism and ignore the history of how shitty it is then maybe you can theoretically imagine a successful version of it. But I don’t need to hypothesize such a scenario. There’s plenty of data and historical facts that completely prove my point
Humanity has progressed a lot in even the last 20 years. Using historical facts to prove something doesn’t work is not effective under these circumstances.
Also communism (in the classical sense) doesn’t really have a practical history, as no country on the planet has purposefully reached it.
The soviet union or china were never communist. They were both horrific state capitalist dictatorships.
And capitalism is also crap. For example look at the impending climate catastrophe.
I’ll never say capitalism is perfect but it’s a system that works - and at its best, it works remarkably well. I hear this argument a lot that communism hasn’t implemented the way it should be. Has there ever been a government that came close to what you would consider “almost good enough” communism?
Communism is by definition a stateless, moneyless, classless society. If any of these exist it is not communism. There is no “almost good enough”. You can’t have almost classless. If you have classes you aren’t classless, and in a single party system the party members are a class.
I put it to you that capitalism doesn’t work. It is an inherently corrupt system that will inevitably end in the destruction of everything. Capitalism is unsustainable. Built on the myth of perpetual growth and willing to kill everything on this planet to achieve that. Given a long enough time-frame all wealth and decision making capabilities under a capitalism will be consolidated in the hands of a couple of rich companies that will only care about economic growth. Damn the consequences.
/sidenote. I am not actually a communist but an Anarchist. I oppose all unjust hierarchies. Money, state and class just happen to all fit under this definition and because of that I also support communism.